A look ahead and what happens next.

The educational challenge

Educating the healthcare workforce to develop, implement and use artificial intelligence (AI) effectively and safely is a multidimensional challenge, involving undergraduate education, postgraduate training, and lifelong learning. This report has presented an overview of a suggested approach and key educational requirements to develop confidence in AI-driven technologies across the healthcare workforce.

At a strategic level, this report can inform how Health Educatin England (HEE), educational and training providers and educators of healthcare workers can plan, resource, develop and deliver education to equip the workforce with the necessary AI knowledge, skills and capabilities.  

Whilst the educational requirements in this report are not a detailed curriculum in themselves, they are intended to inform curriculum development for foundational AI education and advanced content for specific archetypes, and guide learning content for continuing education of qualified professionals throughout the workforce.

Development of a foundational curriculum and the associated content will be an urgent priority.

Educational efforts should be flexible, and include a solid foundation for developing AI-related knowledge as well as personalised advanced elements to fit the needs of individuals in specific roles.

The requirements can assist providers and educators in creating content for their educational and training offerings. They are presented by workforce archetypes to allow tailoring of educational offerings according to the breadth of roles that healthcare professionals will take in the development, implementation and use of AI and other data-driven technologies.

The wider context

Interviewees for this research noted that the success of AI-related education and training will be dependent on wider requirements for transformation and change towards a digital-ready workforce, including the development and education of Digital, Data and Technology (DDaT) data and clinical informatics teams within NHS organisations, including specialised high-level leadership roles. These were explored in detail in Chapter 4.

A key part of this report’s suggested educational approach (section 3.1), involves continuation of the broader efforts to enable change and innovation in healthcare settings, as well as efforts to advance digital skills and capabilities within the workforce as important foundations for specific education and training in AI. When considering wider digital health and data-driven technology education, it may be appropriate to apply the approach this report has taken to structure the workforce into archetypes.

Digital infrastructure and organisational digital maturity are also key enablers of transformation through data-science and AI, without which large-scale adoption of AI technologies will not be possible.

These broader efforts should be considered a priority that will support educational and training offerings to develop healthcare workers’ confidence in AI.

What happens next?

As suggested, the educational requirements identified in this report will need to be adopted through change to educational curricula and the provision of AI-specific content, alongside concrete changes to roles and career paths for specialist AI healthcare workers. The next steps to achieve these can include:

Educational priorities

Produce foundational AI educational content

Concerns about the lack of basic awareness and knowledge about AI amongst most healthcare workers highlight the urgent need for an accessible foundational AI education programme delivered in a scalable format.

Produce flexible post-qualification educational resources

The diversity of skills, roles and educational needs in the existing workforce demands a flexible approach to delivering continuing professional development education. HEE, in collaboration with other partners in the public sector, academic and industry, can work towards producing and collating materials that can be accessed online and potentially personalised through self-assessment. These can be organised according to this report’s archetypes, and the individual’s experiences and interests, and could be available through a centralised online learning hub and/or other platforms like the NHS Digital Academy, the NHS Learning Hub, and AnalystX.43 Curated education journeys will be required to guide learners to the appropriate information to meet their AI learning needs.

Develop product-specific training

A collaborative effort between industry innovators and NHS staff in health settings will enable product-specific training to better reflect the local workflows and clinical settings and meet NHS user needs. The product specific training and a strategy for its use should be present from procurement through to workflow integration.

Next steps by workforce archetypes

Shapers

Shapers will largely work in national organisations that have traditionally been involved in regulation or guidance for healthcare, including within and beyond the remit of HEE and NHS. Both foundational education in AI technologies and more advanced training regarding the governance, validation and implementation of AI technologies would improve Shapers’ abilities to translate their activities into the domain of data-driven algorithms and AI. This can include a healthcare-focussed educational offering for Shapers in national roles.

Drivers

Interviewees for this research highlighted challenges relating to information technology, interoperability, and data governance as major barriers to deploying AI technologies in their settings. Prioritising education for the Driver archetype to support them in making the right strategic and governance decisions relating to AI may help to address these challenges. This can include development of specific educational resources or programmes for senior leaders to enable them to make informed decisions around specific technologies and prepare their organisations for deployment of AI technologies. It should also include engagement and support of ICS leaders to develop workforce plans that ensure appropriate digital, data and technology skills are being developed within the workforce.

Creators and Embedders

Establishing and expanding training opportunities for Creators and Embedders should be considered a priority to fill the significant skill gaps highlighted by this research relating to DDaT data family and clinical informatics skills. These skills are vital not only to support creation and implementation of AI, but also for ongoing monitoring, assurance and audit of AI technologies. New opportunities should be established alongside efforts to upskill existing professionals with digital and data skills and establish flexible training opportunities for digital specialist clinicians. These efforts can be supported by the professionalisation and accreditation of these roles, the development of AI MDT teams, and the establishment of clear professional development and career pathways.

Users

Development of user-related education and training will rely on engagement with undergraduate and postgraduate education providers. HEE does not directly provide education to healthcare professionals in training, but works with organisations like the Royal Colleges, national schools, and universities to advise on educational priorities. Further work is needed to work with these organisations and incorporate AI education into undergraduate and postgraduate curricula and to ensure these are aligned with other areas of education reform.

Many of these identified efforts are already underway, being led by Health Education England, the NHS Transformation Directorate, Integrated Care Systems and trusts, and industry innovators.

A forthcoming project, ‘Establishing healthcare workers’ confidence in AI’, will involve engagement with these organisations and relevant groups and sharing of updates on progress being made on these efforts.

References

43 NHS Transformation Directorate. Learning and development. 2022. https://transform.england.nhs.uk/key-tools-and-info/nhsx-analytics-unit/data-and-analytics-partnership-gateway/learning-and-development/  Accessed July 19, 2022.

Page last reviewed: 20 April 2023
Next review due: 20 April 2024